Repair vs. Replacement: Factors to Consider When Making the Decision

Every building must have a functional, secure roof in order to be used. Otherwise, commercial buildings are shut down until the roof is restored. Depending on the damage, the roof can be repaired or replaced. These are factors that you should consider when trying to make the decision to repair or replace your roof.

Types of Roofing Damage and Repairs

There are many different types of damage that require a commercial roof repair or replacement. In some cases, this is limited to simply repairing a few holes. In other instances, such as with large water- or weather-related problems, there may be more than one option, depending on the severity of the problem. It will help to ask a trusted contractor about the best way to proceed with a particular type of damaged roof so you know your commercial roof repair options are fully considered.

Can the Roof Be Repaired?

The second factor to consider is if the roof can even be repaired. Some types of damage, as well as severely damaged roofs, require replacement. Even if you can repair the roof, repairing it too many times may not be feasible. If it is simply a patch job to fix a few damaged areas, then the repairs likely won’t put stress on the building’s structure. However, leaks and similar types of damage can cause internal damage to a building and roof components, requiring more extensive repairs that will require removing and replacing the roof.

The Cost of Roof Repairs in the Foreseeable Future

The cost of continuing to repair a damaged roof also plays a prominent role in the decision. Many small damage repairs can add up to cost more than replacing a roof. However, minor repairs that happen infrequently will cost less than a total roof replacement. It all depends on how much it will cost to keep doing repairs over the lifespan of the roof.

Depending on the extent of damage, the cost of your commercial roof repair can range dramatically. A simple patch to mend a hole could be inexpensive. In this situation, since you are only paying for necessary materials, the costs are reasonable since you are not paying for labor fees. However, if the damage is much more extensive, then your estimate for repairs may be closer to the high end of what you can expect.

Commercial roof repairs in Tampa are relatively easy with the right help. You need the help of an expert that can assess your roof and guide you in the right direction. If you have questions about commercial flat roof repair in Tampa, schedule a consultation with Aderhold Roofing.

If you need help with your residential or commercial roof, please contact us today.

Aderhold Roofing is a leading commercial roofing company in the Tampa Bay area. Quality work and accurate pricing make it easy to see just how much value you get by working with us. To see the work that we’ve done around Tampa, see our project portfolio here.


Types of Commercial Roofs and Use Cases

Commercial buildings come in a variety of shapes and sizes, and it is important that your building has the right roof. Working with a company like Aderhold Roofing, which is one of the best local commercial roofing companies in Tampa, makes it easier to determine which roof you need on your building. Here is a closer look at the types of commercial roofs and their use cases.

BUR Membrane

BUR membrane roofing is common for commercial properties for its balance between affordability, simplicity, and durability. In essence, it is the standard tar and gravel roof for commercial buildings. It is applied in layers of different materials that create a water-tight barrier when finished. This also makes it more durable against puncture damage from falling objects since it is thicker than other options. Any commercial building that needs a simple, affordable roof that is not visible to the public should consider BUR. The one downside is that it has a rough textured finish that can trap dirt if not cleaned regularly.

Various Metal Options

Metal roofing can be a great way to finish a commercial building. There are many options from galvanized steel to tin. Each metal has its own benefits and weaknesses. For example, tin roofs tend to rust and turn green over time. While this does not mean that it weakens under the rusting process, it will change color over time. On the other hand, stainless steel will not rust or change color, but tends to be much heavier and requires a stronger structure. Commercial buildings of all shapes and sizes can use metal roofs as long as they understand the maintenance and construction requirements.

Heat-Applied Roofing

There are several types of roofing that are applied and melted into place using torches. This heat-applied roofing creates a strong and well-sealed barrier when finished correctly. It is also not prone to problems with high temperatures or temperature fluctuations. Roof coating contractors in Tampa use heat-applied roofing often to create a lasting weatherproof seal on Florida buildings.

Thermoplastic Roofs (PVC and TPO)

Thermoplastic roofs are made of high-temperature-resistant plastics, such as PVC or Thermoplastic Polyolefin (TOP). These options are among the lightest-weight options available, making them perfect for buildings with limited construction strength and size. Small commercial buildings often put them to use. Restaurants also use thermoplastic roofs because they are resistant to staining. Grease and smoke from cooking are often vented out of the roof and these materials will not stick to the thermoplastic, keeping them clean for a long time.

Eco-Friendly (Green) Roofing

If you are looking for a way that your business can help the environment, consider eco-friendly roofing. An eco-friendly roof can take many forms, including using eco-friendly materials or housing plants that both shade the building and give it an interesting look. Green roofs are becoming more popular.

Choosing the right type of roof for your commercial business can be difficult. Work with local commercial roofing companies in Tampa to make the best choice. If you have questions about commercial roofing options, schedule a consultation with Aderhold Roofing.

If you need help with your residential or commercial roof, please contact us today.

Aderhold Roofing is a leading commercial roofing company in the Tampa Bay area. Quality work and accurate pricing make it easy to see just how much value you get by working with us. To see the work that we’ve done around Tampa, see our project portfolio here.


What is Assessed During a Commercial Roof Assessment?

When you have a new building constructed, it will be inspected. The assessment not only clears the building for use according to government regulations but also lets you know that you have a quality roof that is free from problems that could be expensive to fix. There are several factors that go into a roofing assessment that you should be aware of. Here is what is assessed during a commercial roof assessment.


The assessment usually starts with a review of the construction documents, including the permits needed to build the roof. This is to ensure that the roof was built by a licensed roofing contractor in Tampa according to regulations and the roof’s design. If the roof does not pass inspection, that means that the building may be off-limits until it is fixed for the safety of everyone involved. Make sure that the company that you choose pulls the permits before doing work. Otherwise, you may face legal issues even after the construction is finished.


When commercial roofing assessments are completed, they should determine if there is a danger of leaks or other water intrusion issues. After all, leaks in any type of roof can create significant damage to the structure as well as any stored items below them. In fact, a significantly-sized roof leak that goes undetected and unfixed for too long can compromise the structural integrity of a building and lead to it being condemned.

One area that receives a great deal of water leakage is the building envelope. The building envelope assessment will determine if there are cracks, openings, or missing insulation in the building envelope. This is especially critical for those buildings that have single walls, multiple roofs, or are on the bottom of a hill because all of these areas can be highly affected by water penetration.

Structural Design and Execution

The assessment looks for various design issues. If a roof is designed properly according to the standards of commercial roof waterproofing in Tampa, then it should not have structural problems that can lead to water buildup or other problems. The assessment also ensures that the roof was built to exacting specifications for quality. No matter how well a roof is designed, building it below quality standards will lead to problems with your roof later. Catching these types of problems early can significantly reduce your chances of experiencing a problem that will be expensive to fix later.

Commercial roof assessments are absolutely necessary for any business that has a roof system. Having a professional commercial roof assessment conducted on your building can help save you thousands of dollars on future roof repairs and replacements. If you have questions about commercial roofing assessment and commercial roof waterproofing in Tampa, schedule a consultation with Aderhold Roofing.

If you need help with your residential or commercial roof, please contact us today..

Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is for general educational information only. This information does not constitute legal advice, is not intended to constitute legal advice, nor should it be relied upon as legal advice for your specific factual pattern or situation.